Home Improvement Tip: How to Fix A Garage Door Light That Won’t Go Out Automatically


By web gangsta | Published:

Non-Illuminated Doorbell or Garage Door Button
Non-Illuminated Doorbell or Garage Door Button

The other day, Web Watch experienced the same problem other home owners have run into: the light on our automatic garage door opener would not go out.

The opener itself was working perfectly fine.  The door would open or close when requested via the remote or the wall switch, but the lightbulb would not turn off after the 5 minute timer expired.

And Web Watch is seemingly not alone in this problem.  Other websites that specialize in home improvement tips have either left the question unanswered or said that the problem is with the garage door opener’s logic board that prevented the light from automatically turning off.

Web Watch prefers to go with the answer that the kind folks at GENIE GARAGE DOORS gave us when we called after looking through the manual for our opener and not finding the problem listed.  We fully expected to be replacing the opener over the weekend, but wanted to be sure that our decision to do so was correct.  We told the Genie representative that we had run through our usual troubleshooting list:  check the lightbulb, throw the circuit breaker.  Nothing seemed to help.

As our opener was over 10 years old, the person at Genie – without hesitation – said that the first thing we should do is to replace the wall button.

So we went to the local hardware store and picked up the only push button that they had on the shelf that would fit our installation.  We went home, attached the wires to the newly-purchased button switch… and nothing happened.  Sure, the door would activate when the wires were touched, and the door would activate when the wires were initially attached to the switch.  But the switch itself after that?  Nada.

We happened to buy two replacement push buttons, so we could replace two switches at the same time.  Maybe the first button we tried was faulty.  It’s unlikely, but anything is possible.

Nope, the same thing happened with button number 2.

Undaunted, we took a look at the button packaging:  it was a 1 illuminated push button.  Not to exceed 16V.

Maybe it’s the button itself that was not the correct item.  So, as any good home improvement person would do, we made our 2nd trip to the local hardware store to obtain new merchandise for this supposedly 2-minute project.

We looked at the doorbell button selection (because the garage door button selection was minimal at best) and saw that there was also a non-illuminated push button. Not to exceed 23V available.

We bought two of the non-illuminated buttons.  Installed them both.  And they worked perfectly fine…. the garage door light now goes off as expected when the timer limit is reached.

So what did we learn today?

  • Push buttons wear out over time.  And if they feel a bit mushy when pushed, it could end up completing a circuit (to keep a light lit, for example) when you don’t want it to.  Time to replace them.
  • Illuminated buttons and non-illuminated buttons have different voltage requirements.  Be sure to pick the right one for the job.
  • Garage door openers don’t like illuminated buttons.
  • Sometimes trying the $3 answer first is better than assuming you have a $150 problem
  • Always plan on making at least 2 trips to the hardware store for any project you attempt.

3 thoughts on “Home Improvement Tip: How to Fix A Garage Door Light That Won’t Go Out Automatically

  1. Nate Zoner

    I had this exact same problem. Turns out there is an LED wired into the illuminated button that short circuits if you exceed that pesky 16V. The solution: Open up the doorbell button (just two tabs), rip out the LED, put the button back together and it will work perfectly.

  2. Anonymous Dude

    I had this exact same problem with my garage door opener. Replacing the wall button ($8 from Home Depot) fixed it…way cheaper than a logic board or new garage door opener.

  3. R Duran

    We had the same problem with the light not turning off.
    I found out I wasn’t pushing the button enough (till it clicked) , problem solved.

Comments are closed.